Orioles 3, Yankees 2: Mayo Buries Headrick After Weathers’ No-Hit Bid Ends

The lead

May 11, 2026 - Baltimore - The Baltimore Orioles flipped Camden Yards from silence to pandemonium in one swing. Ryan Weathers carried a no-hit bid into the seventh for the New York Yankees, Adley Rutschman opened the frame with a single up the middle to end it, Aaron Boone went to Brent Headrick after a one-out walk, and Coby Mayo greeted him with a three-run homer to left that stood as Baltimore’s 3-2 win on Monday night, per the Associated Press recap on CBS Sports.

AP said Mayo entered hitting .158 before driving Headrick’s third pitch into the seats. Weathers struck out nine, walked three, and threw 101 pitches.

How the game turned

Ben Rice’s two-run homer in the third had New York ahead early. The inning lines held until Rutschman’s knock—then Mayo’s blast off the bullpen—reshuffled leverage for good.

Dietrich Enns (1-0) earned the win in relief of Brandon Young, and rookie Anthony Nunez recorded three outs for his second save. Camilo Doval followed Headrick with a scoreless inning for the Yankees, who AP noted have dropped four straight.

Pitching and matchup notes

Weathers’ line still reflected tight traffic once the bid broke: 6 1/3 innings, the first Baltimore hit, and the runs charged after the change to Headrick. For the Orioles, Young set the table before Enns and Nunez kept the late lead intact.

Bats that changed the board

Mayo’s swing turned a 2-0 deficit into 3-2 in one at-bat, pairing patience from Rutschman and Tyler O’Neill with a barrel when Headrick had to attack the zone. Rice’s early shot kept New York in command until the seventh’s sudden inversion.

AthX Engine fantasy angle

Weathers piled up 21.33 AthX Engine pitching FP on AthX Engine even as Baltimore rallied off the pen—dominant innings out of the rotation still register before the inning unravels. Mayo added 8 AthX Engine hitting FP in the same scoring window. The Orioles’ 7 AthX Engine team FP ranked fifth among Monday winners—one swing can move club totals harder than a quiet multi-hit night elsewhere. AthX Engine differs from dynamic pricing.

What comes next

New York heads home searching for a stopper after four losses while Baltimore pushes a momentum win against an opponent that had the spotlight until the seventh unraveled.

*Sources: MLB.com schedule, MLB gameday wrap, CBS Sports recap, Associated Press via CBS, and AthX Engine scoring. Information only; not financial advice.*